Who is this book for?
- Readers who enjoy slow-burn literary mysteries with complex characters and rich settings would likely appreciate this book.
- Fans of multi-layered narratives that explore social issues, family dynamics, and historical contexts will find much to engage with.
- Those who appreciate atmospheric writing and don't mind a slower pace for the sake of character development and intricate plotting would be drawn to this novel.
- Readers interested in stories set in the 1970s, particularly those involving summer camps and small-town dynamics, will find the setting compelling.
Who is unlikely to appreciate this book?
- Readers seeking a fast-paced thriller or straightforward mystery might find this book frustrating.
- Those who prefer linear narratives or dislike multiple POVs and time jumps may struggle with the structure.
- Readers looking for light summer reading or those who are sensitive to themes of child disappearance and family trauma might want to avoid this book.
- Additionally, those familiar with the Adirondack region who expect accurate local representation may be disappointed.
- Readers who prefer concise storytelling or are impatient with slow-building plots might find the length and pacing challenging.
Things online reviewers enjoyed about this book
- Exceptional characterization, especially of the women characters
- Rich, multilayered plot with complex characters
- Vivid and lush setting in the Adirondacks
- Explores themes of motherhood, gender roles, sexuality, identity, and class
- Non-linear timeline adds to the drama and suspense
- Transports readers effectively to the 1970s setting
- Compelling page-turner with intriguing mysteries
- Well-constructed slow-burn plot that builds tension
- Powerful and intense read that evokes a range of emotions
- Beautifully written with attention to detail
Things people didn't like as much about this book
- Slow-moving pace, especially in the beginning
- Multiple POVs and split timeline can be confusing for some readers
- Some character decisions may seem unrealistic or frustrating
- The ending may feel unsatisfying or predictable to some
- Excessive number of characters, making it difficult to keep track
- The portrayal of Adirondack residents may be seen as stereotypical or insulting
- At 500 pages, some readers find it unnecessarily long
- The connection between the two mysteries (Barbara and Bear) may feel forced
- Some readers find the characters one-dimensional or hard to connect with
- The literary elements may feel forced or irrelevant to some readers
