The Black Bird Oracle

by

Deborah Harkness

Should you read this book?

The best public reviews summarized for you.

Who is this book for?

  • Fans of the All Souls series who are invested in Diana and Matthew's story will likely enjoy this continuation.
  • Readers who appreciate deep dives into family history, complex magical systems, and atmospheric fantasy with historical elements will find much to love.
  • Those who enjoy slow-burn narratives that focus on character development and world-building, particularly in the realm of witchcraft and supernatural abilities, will be drawn to this book.
  • It's also ideal for readers who don't mind a story that sets up future installments and are patient with gradual plot development.

Who is unlikely to appreciate this book?

  • Readers expecting the same level of action, romance, and urgency as the original trilogy may be disappointed.
  • Those who prefer fast-paced narratives with clear resolutions might find the pacing slow and the ending unsatisfying.
  • Newcomers to the series will likely feel lost without prior knowledge of the characters and world.
  • Readers who are not fond of extensive magical theory, family genealogies, or information-heavy passages may struggle with parts of the book.
  • Additionally, those who are particularly attached to the characterizations from previous books might be frustrated by perceived inconsistencies or changes in familiar characters.

Things online reviewers enjoyed about this book

  • Thrilling return to the All Souls Universe
  • Exploration of Diana's paternal family and their magical heritage
  • Introduction of higher magic and new magical concepts
  • Delightful scenes with Diana and Matthew's twins
  • Rich flashbacks and memories that provide interesting Easter eggs
  • Continuation of the beloved characters' stories
  • Well-crafted blend of history, fantasy, and contemporary narrative
  • Strong family bonds and diverse characters
  • Atmospheric storytelling that immerses readers
  • Setup for future installments in the series

Things people didn't like as much about this book

  • Slower pace compared to previous books in the series
  • Less focus on Matthew and other beloved characters
  • Some plot points feel unresolved or anticlimactic
  • Character inconsistencies, particularly with Diana and Sarah
  • Excessive information dumps and complex family histories
  • Lack of the same spark and passion from the original trilogy
  • Some readers found the story flat or lacking in high stakes
  • Abrupt ending that feels more like a setup for the next book
  • Overlong and in need of editing according to some readers
  • Deviation from established rules of the universe for plot twists

If you like this book, you should consider reading:

by Leigh Bardugo
by Robert Galbraith

About

Privacy Policy

RSS Feed