Madness: Race and Insanity in a Jim Crow Asylum

by

Antonia Hylton

Should you read this book?

The best public reviews summarized for you.

Who is this book for?

  • This book would likely appeal to readers interested in African American history, civil rights, and the intersection of race and healthcare in the United States.
  • Those who enjoy investigative journalism and are looking to learn about lesser-known aspects of American history would find value in this work.
  • Readers who appreciate personal narratives woven into historical accounts and those studying or working in fields related to mental health, social justice, or public policy would also be drawn to this book.
  • It would resonate with individuals seeking to understand systemic racism and its long-term effects on communities and institutions.

Who is unlikely to appreciate this book?

  • Readers who prefer strictly linear historical narratives or those who dislike frequent shifts in focus might struggle with this book.
  • Those looking for a more academic or traditionally structured historical text may find the writing style and organization frustrating.
  • Individuals who are sensitive to descriptions of mental health abuses or racial injustices might find parts of the book distressing.
  • Readers who prefer their non-fiction to be devoid of personal anecdotes from the author may be put off by the inclusion of the author's family history.
  • Those expecting a comprehensive history of Crownsville Hospital alone might be disappointed by the broader scope of topics covered.

Things online reviewers enjoyed about this book

  • Well-researched and informative account of an important but overlooked historical topic
  • Sheds light on systemic racism in mental health treatment
  • Provides personal stories and interviews that humanize the patients
  • Blends historical research with the author's personal family experiences
  • Highlights the injustices and abuses that occurred at Crownsville Hospital
  • Offers insights into the broader civil rights struggle and healthcare inequalities
  • Compelling and emotionally impactful storytelling
  • Brings attention to the intersection of race and mental health treatment
  • Includes perspectives from both patients and staff members
  • Contributes to a more complete understanding of American history

Things people didn't like as much about this book

  • Disorganized structure and narrative flow
  • Jumps between topics and time periods, making it hard to follow at times
  • Some readers found the writing style clunky or colloquial
  • Inclusion of author's personal family story felt distracting to some
  • Repetition of certain points and information
  • Lack of clear focus on the asylum itself for a significant portion of the book
  • Some readers felt there was an overreliance on opinion rather than facts
  • Inconsistent use of pronouns and some grammatical errors
  • Not enough explanation of the significance of certain situations or conditions
  • Some readers found it challenging to get through due to writing style

If you like this book, you should consider reading:

About

Privacy Policy

RSS Feed