Who is this book for?
- Readers who enjoy dark fantasy with gothic elements and complex magic systems are likely to appreciate this book.
- Fans of multiple POV narratives and character-driven stories will find depth in the expanded cast.
- Those who love morally gray characters, especially snarky anti-heroes like the Nightmare, will be drawn to his arc. Readers who prefer fast-paced action in the latter half of books and don't mind a slower build-up will find the climax satisfying.
- Anyone who enjoyed the first book in the series and wants to see the world and characters further developed will likely enjoy this conclusion.
Who is unlikely to appreciate this book?
- Readers expecting a direct continuation of Elspeth's story from the first book may be disappointed by her reduced role.
- Those who dislike multiple POVs or find frequent perspective switches disruptive might struggle with the narrative structure.
- Fans of slow-burn romance may be put off by the seemingly rushed relationship between Elm and Ione.
- Readers seeking a strong horror element or hoping for a darker, more gothic tone throughout may find the book less satisfying than the first.
- Those who are sensitive to editing issues or typos might find these distracting from the overall story.
Things online reviewers enjoyed about this book
- Beautiful, atmospheric writing that enhances the dark, gothic fantasy elements
- The Nightmare character is compelling and steals the show with his snarky humor and complex backstory
- Expands on the world-building and lore in interesting ways
- Action-packed and emotional ending that provides a satisfying conclusion
- Multiple POVs add depth to secondary characters like Elm
- Banter and humor, especially between the Nightmare and Ravyn, is entertaining
- Explores deeper themes of sacrifice, love, and redemption
- The father-figure relationship between the Nightmare and Elspeth is touching
- Answers lingering questions from the first book
- Fast-paced and engaging in the latter half
Things people didn't like as much about this book
- Pacing issues, especially in the first half of the book
- Elspeth, the main character from book one, is sidelined for much of the story
- The romance between Elm and Ione feels rushed and underdeveloped to some readers
- Frequent POV switches can be jarring and disrupt the flow
- Some plot points and character motivations are unclear or confusing
- The gothic horror elements are less prominent than in the first book
- Several readers noted typos and editing issues
- Some storylines and character arcs feel disconnected from the main plot
- Lack of romantic development between Elspeth and Ravyn disappoints some fans
- Predictable plot twists for some readers
