Somewhere Beyond the Sea

by

T.J. Klune

Should you read this book?

The best public reviews summarized for you.

Who is this book for?

  • Fans of The House in the Cerulean Sea looking for more of the same cozy, heartwarming atmosphere.
  • Readers who enjoy found family stories with magical elements and diverse characters.
  • Those seeking LGBTQ+ representation in fantasy literature, especially in a feel-good setting.
  • People who appreciate books with strong messages about acceptance, inclusivity, and fighting discrimination.
  • Readers who enjoy character-driven stories focusing on personal growth and overcoming trauma.

Who is unlikely to appreciate this book?

  • Those who prefer subtle messaging and dislike overt political or social commentary in their fiction.
  • Readers looking for complex, nuanced explorations of systemic issues rather than simplified good vs. bad narratives.
  • People who are sensitive to potential cultural appropriation or white savior narratives in literature.
  • Readers who expect significant plot development or high-stakes conflict in their fantasy stories.
  • Those who dislike repetitive themes or dialogue, especially when delivered by child characters.

Things online reviewers enjoyed about this book

  • Heartwarming and delightful continuation of the beloved characters from The House in the Cerulean Sea
  • Wonderful exploration of found family dynamics and unconditional love
  • Humorous and entertaining interactions between the magical children
  • Strong themes of acceptance, inclusivity, and standing up against discrimination
  • Compelling character development, especially for Arthur and the children
  • Cozy and comforting atmosphere that feels like a warm hug
  • Powerful messages about fighting fear and prejudice
  • Introduction of lovable new character David the yeti
  • Emotional depth in exploring Arthur's backstory and trauma
  • Satisfying continuation for fans of the first book

Things people didn't like as much about this book

  • Heavy-handed and repetitive messaging that can feel preachy at times
  • Plot and conflict resolution may feel simplistic or predictable to some readers
  • Less subtle and nuanced than the first book in addressing social issues
  • Some readers found the children's dialogue unrealistic for their ages
  • Pacing issues, with some finding the middle section slow
  • Controversial use of Indigenous trauma as inspiration without proper acknowledgment
  • Accusations of white saviorism in the portrayal of Arthur and Linus
  • Lack of exploration of the children's individual cultures and backgrounds
  • Some found it too similar to the first book without enough new elements
  • Ending felt rushed or too convenient for some readers

If you like this book, you should consider reading:

by Mò Xiāng Tóng Xiù, Marina Privalova, Jin Fang
by Shelby Van Pelt

About

Privacy Policy

RSS Feed