Empire of the Summer Moon: Quanah Parker and the Rise and Fall of the Comanches, the Most Powerful Indian Tribe in American History

by

S.C. Gwynne

Should you read this book?

The best public reviews summarized for you.

Who is this book for?

  • History buffs interested in the American West and Native American conflicts.
  • Readers who enjoy vivid narratives of frontier life and warfare.
  • Those curious about Comanche history and their dominance of the Southern Plains.
  • Fans of military history who want to learn about cavalry tactics and Indian Wars.
  • People interested in the story of Cynthia Ann Parker and Quanah Parker.

Who is unlikely to appreciate this book?

  • Readers sensitive to graphic depictions of violence and atrocities.
  • Those looking for a culturally sensitive portrayal of Native American history.
  • People seeking a more balanced or Native American perspective on events.
  • Readers expecting an in-depth biography focused primarily on Quanah Parker.
  • Those who prefer academic historical writing to popular narrative history.

Things online reviewers enjoyed about this book

  • Well-researched and comprehensive history of the Comanche tribe
  • Vividly describes the Comanche's military prowess and dominance of the Southern Plains
  • Provides fascinating details about Comanche culture and way of life
  • Tells the compelling story of Cynthia Ann Parker and her son Quanah Parker
  • Offers an engaging narrative of the conflicts between settlers and Native Americans
  • Gives insight into the development of the Texas Rangers and frontier warfare
  • Describes the impact of technological changes like firearms on the balance of power
  • Provides context on the broader history of westward expansion in America
  • Written in an accessible, page-turning style for general readers
  • Sheds light on a lesser-known but important part of American history

Things people didn't like as much about this book

  • Uses outdated and offensive terminology to describe Native Americans
  • Presents a biased, Eurocentric perspective on the conflicts
  • Focuses more on violence and warfare than Comanche culture and daily life
  • Relies heavily on white settler accounts rather than Native American sources
  • Makes questionable generalizations about Native American cultures
  • Romanticizes and sensationalizes violence at times
  • Does not fully deliver on promise to focus on Quanah Parker
  • Lacks nuance in portrayal of complex historical events and motivations
  • Perpetuates stereotypes of Native Americans as primitive or savage
  • Fails to adequately explore Comanche perspective on events

If you like this book, you should consider reading:

About

Privacy Policy

RSS Feed