Elphie: A Wicked Childhood

by

Gregory Maguire

Should you read this book?

The best public reviews summarized for you.

Who is this book for?

  • Diehard fans of Maguire's Wicked Years book series who want more backstory.
  • Readers who enjoy Maguire's introspective, flowery writing style.
  • Those interested in the political and social dynamics of Oz.
  • Fans of character-driven stories focused on childhood and coming-of-age.
  • People who appreciate books that require close reading and analysis.

Who is unlikely to appreciate this book?

  • Casual fans of the Wicked musical looking for a similar tone and style.
  • Readers who prefer straightforward plots with clear narratives.
  • Those unfamiliar with the Wicked Years series who want a standalone story.
  • People who dislike overly descriptive or verbose writing.
  • Readers expecting a lot of action or major plot developments.

Things online reviewers enjoyed about this book

  • Provides deeper insight into Elphaba's early childhood and adolescence
  • Shows defining moments that shape Elphaba's character
  • Explores the Thropp family dynamic and relationships between siblings
  • Contains Easter eggs and nods to the Wicked musical
  • Offers more background on key events only referenced in the original book
  • Establishes Elphaba's first encounters with talking Animals and magic
  • Features Maguire's signature whimsical and introspective writing style
  • Adds more context to the world of Oz and its politics
  • Introduces new characters like Unger who serve as important mentors for Elphaba
  • Provides continuity and connections to the other Wicked Years books

Things people didn't like as much about this book

  • Slow pacing with not much plot or action happening
  • Overly flowery and verbose writing style that can be hard to follow
  • Doesn't stand well on its own as a story without knowledge of the other books
  • Characters, including Elphaba, don't feel fully developed
  • Tone and style differ from the original Wicked novel
  • Many readers found it boring or difficult to get through
  • Lacks a clear narrative structure
  • Some inconsistencies with established character backgrounds
  • Feels unnecessary or like a cash grab to some fans
  • Doesn't add much new information for those already familiar with the series

About

Privacy Policy

RSS Feed