To Rescue the Constitution: George Washington and the Fragile American Experiment

by

Bret Baier, Catherine Whitney

Should you read this book?

The best public reviews summarized for you.

Who is this book for?

  • This book would likely appeal to readers with a general interest in American history, particularly those looking for an accessible introduction to the founding of the United States and George Washington's role in it.
  • History enthusiasts who enjoy narrative non-fiction and want to deepen their understanding of the Constitutional era would find value in this book.
  • It would also appeal to those interested in leadership studies, as it highlights Washington's pivotal role in shaping the nation.
  • Readers who appreciate drawing parallels between historical events and current political climates would find the book's perspective engaging.

Who is unlikely to appreciate this book?

  • Advanced scholars or experts in American Revolutionary history might find this book too basic or lacking in new information.
  • Readers seeking a more critical or nuanced examination of Washington's character and actions may be disappointed by the somewhat idealized portrayal.
  • Those who prefer highly detailed, academic treatments of historical events might find the narrative style and broad overview unsatisfying.
  • Additionally, readers looking for an in-depth exploration of other founding fathers or a comprehensive analysis of the Constitutional Convention debates beyond Washington's role may find the focus too narrow.

Things online reviewers enjoyed about this book

  • Provides a clear and understandable overview of complex historical events
  • Offers insights into George Washington's leadership and character
  • Highlights the challenges faced in forming the United States
  • Reads smoothly, almost like fiction despite being non-fiction
  • Gives a comprehensive understanding of the Constitutional Convention
  • Humanizes Washington, showing his vulnerabilities and personal struggles
  • Demonstrates Washington's unwavering commitment to the Constitution
  • Offers new information even for those familiar with the time period
  • Explores Washington's relationships with family and other founding fathers
  • Addresses Washington's conflicting views on slavery
  • Provides context for current political divisions in America

Things people didn't like as much about this book

  • May be repetitive for those already well-versed in American Revolutionary history
  • Some sections can feel like a textbook rather than a narrative
  • Lacks new revelations for American history experts
  • May idealize Washington too much, not critically reflecting on his failures
  • Glosses over some crucial historical moments
  • Doesn't provide enough detail on disagreements among other constitutional framers
  • Can be boring at times for readers seeking more in-depth analysis
  • Epilogue discussing modern views on the Constitution may be too partisan
  • Co-authorship with a lesser-known writer may raise questions about authenticity
  • Simplifies some complex historical events

If you like this book, you should consider reading:

About

Privacy Policy

RSS Feed