Who is this book for?
- This book would likely appeal to readers interested in true crime, American history, Native American issues, and investigative journalism.
- Those who enjoy narrative non-fiction that reads like a thriller would appreciate Grann's storytelling approach.
- History buffs fascinated by lesser-known events and conspiracy theories from the early 20th century would find the content engaging.
- Readers concerned with social justice issues, particularly related to the exploitation of Native Americans, would find the book's themes compelling and relevant.
Who is unlikely to appreciate this book?
- Readers who prefer lighter subject matter or fiction may find this book too disturbing or depressing given its focus on real-life murders and systemic racism.
- Those who dislike detailed historical accounts or prefer more action-oriented narratives might find parts of the book slow or dry.
- Readers expecting a comprehensive history of the FBI's formation based on the subtitle may be disappointed by the relatively limited focus on that aspect.
- Those who are sensitive to descriptions of violence or prefer their non-fiction to maintain more emotional distance from its subjects may struggle with some of the content.
Things online reviewers enjoyed about this book
- Exposes a shocking and little-known chapter of American history
- Reveals the systematic murder of wealthy Osage Indians in 1920s Oklahoma
- Provides insight into early FBI operations and J. Edgar Hoover
- Well-researched with access to previously unavailable documents
- Reads like a gripping murder mystery or thriller
- Sheds light on racism and exploitation of Native Americans
- Contains compelling historical photographs
- Highlights heroic investigators who solved the case
- Explores long-lasting impacts on Osage descendants
- Uncovers broader conspiracy beyond just a few perpetrators
Things people didn't like as much about this book
- Writing style can be dry or clunky at times
- Some readers found it repetitive or overly long
- Less focus on FBI origins than title suggests
- Occasionally confusing or hard to follow all the characters
- May be too disturbing or graphic for some readers
- Some felt it lacked emotional depth in portraying victims
- A few questioned reliability of certain historical sources used
- Pacing issues – slow in parts for some readers
- Could have provided more context on broader Native American history
- Ending felt anticlimactic to some after buildup
