Who is this book for?
- Readers who enjoy fast-paced, action-packed mystery thrillers with multiple plotlines would likely enjoy this book.
- Fans of James Patterson's writing style, with its short chapters and quick pacing, will find familiar elements to appreciate.
- Those who like ensemble casts of quirky detectives solving crimes in urban settings may be drawn to the Holmes, Marple and Poe team.
- Readers looking for light, entertaining mysteries without too much graphic violence or heavy themes could find this a fun, escapist read.
- The book may also appeal to those who enjoy modern takes on classic detective characters.
Who is unlikely to appreciate this book?
- Readers seeking more traditional, methodical mystery novels with complex deductions and realistic police procedures may be disappointed by this book.
- Those who prefer deeply developed characters and intricate, tightly-plotted single mysteries might find the multiple cases and rapid pace unsatisfying.
- Literary fiction fans or readers expecting a more serious homage to the classic detectives may dislike the lighter, more action-oriented approach.
- Critics of formulaic thrillers or those sensitive to stereotypical character portrayals, especially of women, might take issue with some aspects of the writing.
- Purists of Sherlock Holmes, Miss Marple, or Edgar Allan Poe lore may be put off by the liberties taken with the characters' namesakes.
Things online reviewers enjoyed about this book
- Fast-paced and engaging narrative with short, punchy chapters
- Interesting and unique main characters with mysterious backgrounds
- Multiple intriguing cases and plotlines
- Humorous moments and witty banter between characters
- Nods to the original literary detectives the characters are named after
- Exciting action scenes, especially involving Poe's love of fast cars
- Intriguing mystery surrounding the true identities of Holmes, Marple and Poe
- Strong supporting characters like Detective Helene Grey and Virginia the office manager
- New York City setting adds atmosphere
- Potential for an ongoing series with more character development
Things people didn't like as much about this book
- Too many cases/plotlines crammed into one book, making it feel scattered
- Lack of depth in character development for the main trio
- Some cases are solved too easily or conveniently
- Over-the-top, unrealistic scenarios that strain credibility
- Lack of complex deduction or clever mystery-solving
- Simplistic or stereotypical portrayal of some characters
- Inconsistent characterization, especially of Marple's age/appearance
- Objectification of female characters in some descriptions
- Unresolved plotlines and loose ends
- Writing quality described as basic or lacking literary flair by some
