The Wager: A Tale of Shipwreck, Mutiny and Murder

by

David Grann

Should you read this book?

The best public reviews summarized for you.

Who is this book for?

  • Readers who enjoy meticulously researched historical non-fiction with a focus on maritime adventures and survival stories would likely appreciate this book.
  • Those fascinated by 18th century naval history, tales of shipwrecks and mutinies, or explorations of human nature under extreme circumstances would find much to engage with.
  • The book would appeal to fans of authors like Patrick O'Brian or narratives like 'Endurance'.
  • Readers who appreciate nuanced examinations of historical events and don't mind grappling with conflicting accounts and moral ambiguities would also find this book rewarding.

Who is unlikely to appreciate this book?

  • Readers looking for a fast-paced, action-packed adventure story may be disappointed by the sometimes slow pacing and detailed historical context.
  • Those who prefer clear-cut heroes and villains or straightforward narratives might struggle with the complex, morally ambiguous characters and competing versions of events.
  • Readers sensitive to descriptions of violence, starvation, or other harsh realities of survival may find some passages disturbing.
  • Those who dislike authorial editorializing on historical events or attempts to draw modern parallels might be put off by some of Grann's commentary.
  • Finally, readers expecting a tight focus on the shipwreck and immediate aftermath, as suggested by some marketing materials, may be frustrated by the broader scope of the book.

Things online reviewers enjoyed about this book

  • Painstakingly well-researched historical non-fiction
  • Gripping and thought-provoking story of survival and human nature
  • Vivid imagery and immersive prose that transports readers to another time and place
  • Seamless blend of suspense and historical context
  • Provides rich insights into 18th century naval life and maritime history
  • Compelling characterizations of key figures like Captain Cheap and John Byron
  • Masterful presentation of conflicting accounts while maintaining a seamless narrative
  • Valuable side discussions on topics like scurvy and indigenous peoples
  • Thrilling account of naval battles and treasure hunting
  • Explores fascinating themes of narrative control and competing truths

Things people didn't like as much about this book

  • Pacing and level of detail can be uneven at times
  • Some readers found it difficult to connect with or distinguish between characters
  • Attempts to contextualize within imperialism felt forced to some readers
  • Occasional editorializing and moralizing by the author
  • Less taut narrative structure compared to some of Grann's previous works
  • Anticlimactic resolution of the central 'mystery'
  • Some found it boring or sluggish, especially in the early sections
  • Gruesome details of survival may be off-putting to some readers
  • Audiobook narration was criticized by some as overly dramatic
  • Marketing/blurb may have created misleading expectations about the focus of the book

If you like this book, you should consider reading:

About

Privacy Policy

RSS Feed