Sword Catcher

by

Cassandra Clare

Should you read this book?

The best public reviews summarized for you.

Who is this book for?

  • Readers who enjoy immersive, politically-focused adult fantasy with intricate world-building are likely to appreciate Sword Catcher.
  • Fans of slow-burn stories that prioritize character development and complex societal dynamics over action will find much to love.
  • Those who enjoy diverse casts and LGBTQ+ representation in their fantasy will also be drawn to this book.
  • Readers who are patient with lengthy expositions and are looking for the start of a new epic fantasy series to invest in will likely be satisfied with Clare's foray into adult fantasy.

Who is unlikely to appreciate this book?

  • Readers seeking fast-paced, action-packed fantasy may find Sword Catcher too slow and detail-oriented.
  • Those who prefer concise storytelling or are easily overwhelmed by extensive world-building and political machinations may struggle with the book's length and pacing.
  • Fans expecting a romance-heavy plot or looking for a standalone novel might be disappointed.
  • Readers sensitive to potential cultural appropriation or stereotyping in fantasy settings may take issue with some of Clare's portrayals.
  • Additionally, those who dislike information dumps or excessive descriptive passages may find the writing style frustrating.

Things online reviewers enjoyed about this book

  • Rich and immersive world-building with vivid details
  • Successfully transitions from YA to adult fantasy in tone and content
  • Intriguing political intrigue and complex plot
  • Strong character development, especially for protagonists Kel and Lin
  • Diverse and LGBTQ+ inclusive cast of characters
  • Interesting magic system and lore
  • Compelling audiobook narration
  • Sets up an exciting series with potential for growth
  • Explores themes of loyalty, identity, and power dynamics
  • Engaging writing style that draws readers in

Things people didn't like as much about this book

  • Slow pacing and excessive length that could have been edited down
  • Information dumps and overly detailed descriptions that can be tedious
  • Lack of action and excitement for much of the book
  • Underdeveloped romance elements despite being marketed as such
  • Some characters feel one-dimensional or underutilized
  • Plot threads that feel disconnected or unresolved
  • Similarities to other fantasy works that may feel derivative to some readers
  • Worldbuilding elements that can be confusing or poorly explained
  • Controversial portrayal of certain ethnicities and cultures
  • Doesn't fully deliver on the premise of the 'sword catcher' concept

If you like this book, you should consider reading:

by Deborah Harkness

About

Privacy Policy

RSS Feed