Why We Love Baseball: A History in 50 Moments

by

Joe Posnanski

Should you read this book?

The best public reviews summarized for you.

Who is this book for?

  • This book would likely appeal to dedicated baseball fans who enjoy diving deep into the sport's history and lore.
  • Readers who appreciate a mix of famous moments and obscure stories from throughout baseball's past would find much to enjoy.
  • Those who like personal, anecdotal storytelling about sports and don't mind a blend of facts, myths, and personal perspectives would be drawn to Posnanski's style.
  • Fans of baseball writing that goes beyond just recounting events to explore the cultural and emotional impact of the game would particularly appreciate this book.

Who is unlikely to appreciate this book?

  • Casual baseball fans or those new to the sport might find the book overwhelming or too detailed.
  • Readers who prefer a more straightforward, chronological history of baseball might be frustrated by the format of 50 separate moments.
  • Those who are sensitive to potential factual errors or who strongly disagree with the author's selections might be put off.
  • People who don't enjoy sports writing that mixes personal anecdotes and opinions with historical recounting may not appreciate Posnanski's style.
  • Lastly, readers looking for a critical examination of baseball's problems rather than a celebration of the sport might find the book's tone too positive.

Things online reviewers enjoyed about this book

  • Exuberant and entertaining look at baseball history
  • Diverse stories covering famous and obscure moments
  • Includes moments from all 30 current MLB franchises
  • Humorous and heartfelt storytelling
  • Covers a wide range of baseball history, from early days to modern era
  • Includes stories from minor leagues, Negro Leagues, and international baseball
  • Author's enthusiasm and love for the game shines through
  • Thorough research and interviews provide new perspectives on well-known events
  • Respectful treatment of racism and other issues in baseball history
  • Engaging writing style that feels like listening to stories from a knowledgeable fan

Things people didn't like as much about this book

  • Some readers may disagree with the selection or ranking of moments
  • A few factual errors noted by some reviewers
  • Writing style can come across as condescending to some readers
  • Format may feel disjointed or repetitive for some
  • Audiobook quality is uneven between narrators
  • Some readers found the book too long for the format
  • Author's personal connections and anecdotes may not appeal to all readers
  • Lack of audio clips or additional voices in the audiobook version
  • May be too detailed for casual baseball fans
  • Some readers felt the content would work better as an app or daily digest

If you like this book, you should consider reading:

About

Privacy Policy

RSS Feed