Who is this book for?
- Readers who enjoy glamorous historical fiction set in Old Hollywood would likely love this book.
- It will appeal to those interested in LGBTQ+ stories, particularly about queer women in the past having to hide their identities.
- Fans of complex, morally gray female protagonists will appreciate Evelyn's character.
- Those who like emotional love stories with dramatic plot twists will find the romance compelling.
- Readers interested in themes of ambition, fame, and the dark side of stardom will be drawn in by the exploration of Evelyn's rise to success.
Who is unlikely to appreciate this book?
- Readers looking for literary fiction with more nuanced prose may find the writing style too simplistic.
- Those who prefer strictly historically accurate portrayals may be frustrated by some of the more modern sensibilities.
- Readers sensitive to depictions of toxic relationships may dislike aspects of Evelyn and Celia's romance.
- Those who want likable protagonists may struggle with Evelyn's morally questionable actions.
- Readers expecting a light, fluffy romance may find the darker themes and plot twists unsettling.
- Those who dislike frame narratives or dual timelines may be less engaged by the present-day sections with Monique.
Things online reviewers enjoyed about this book
- Compelling and page-turning story about Old Hollywood
- Complex, flawed but fascinating main character in Evelyn Hugo
- Explores themes of ambition, fame, love, and identity
- Strong LGBTQ+ representation and relationships
- Portrays diverse characters and interracial relationships
- Emotional and moving love story at its core
- Glamorous setting and time period of 1950s-1980s Hollywood
- Tackles issues of sexism, homophobia, and racism in the film industry
- Surprising plot twists and reveals throughout
- Examines the sacrifices made for success and stardom
Things people didn't like as much about this book
- Some found the writing style simplistic or lacking depth
- Monique's present-day storyline less engaging than Evelyn's past
- Portrayal of men mostly negative or one-dimensional
- Main romance between Evelyn and Celia seen as toxic by some readers
- Plot twists predictable or contrived for some
- Handling of race and identity issues felt superficial to some
- Evelyn not always likable as a character
- Pacing issues – slow start for some readers
- Ending felt rushed or unsatisfying to some
- Repetitive writing in parts
