Uncomfortable Conversations with a Jew

by

Emmanuel Acho, Noa Tishby

Should you read this book?

The best public reviews summarized for you.

Who is this book for?

  • This book would likely appeal to readers who are curious about Judaism, antisemitism, and the complexities of Jewish identity but have limited prior knowledge.
  • It would be particularly suitable for non-Jewish readers seeking to understand current events related to Israel and antisemitism, especially in the context of the October 7th, 2023 attacks and their aftermath.
  • Those who appreciate dialogue-based explorations of sensitive topics and are open to learning about different perspectives on Jewish issues would find value in this book.
  • It may also appeal to readers who enjoyed Emmanuel Acho's previous work on racial issues and are interested in his approach to Jewish topics.

Who is unlikely to appreciate this book?

  • Readers who are already well-versed in Jewish history, culture, and contemporary issues might find this book too basic or lacking in new insights.
  • Those seeking a more critical examination of Israeli policies or a deeper exploration of Palestinian perspectives may be disappointed by what they perceive as a pro-Israel bias.
  • Academics or readers looking for a more comprehensive and nuanced analysis of antisemitism and Jewish identity might find the book's approach too simplistic.
  • Additionally, those who prefer traditional narrative non-fiction over a conversational format might struggle with the book's structure.
  • Jewish readers looking for representation of diverse Jewish experiences beyond the Ashkenazi and Israeli perspectives may also find the book lacking.

Things online reviewers enjoyed about this book

  • Provides informative and accessible explanations of complex topics related to antisemitism and Jewish history
  • Offers insights into the events surrounding October 7th, 2023 and their aftermath
  • Addresses difficult and uncomfortable questions about Jews, Israel, and antisemitism
  • Presents different perspectives through the dialogue between the two authors
  • Helps clarify misconceptions about Jews and Israel
  • Offers a good overview of Jewish history and the Holocaust
  • Demonstrates how people with different backgrounds can have productive conversations
  • Provides analogies to make complex topics more relatable
  • Addresses current issues of antisemitism on college campuses
  • Offers hope for better understanding between different groups

Things people didn't like as much about this book

  • Some readers feel it's too focused on Israel and Zionism rather than American Jewish experiences
  • May not provide enough depth for readers already knowledgeable about Judaism
  • Some perceive a bias towards a pro-Israel perspective
  • Lacks substantial coverage of Mizrahi Jews, Black Jews, and other Jewish diversity
  • Some readers find the conversation format less effective than a traditional narrative
  • May oversimplify complex historical and political issues
  • Some perceive a lack of balance in discussing Palestinian perspectives
  • Copyediting issues, particularly with Hebrew text
  • Some readers feel it doesn't adequately address criticisms of Israeli policies
  • May not provide enough new information for Jewish readers already familiar with the topics

If you like this book, you should consider reading:

About

Privacy Policy

RSS Feed