Lady Tan’s Circle of Women

by

Lisa See

Should you read this book?

The best public reviews summarized for you.

Who is this book for?

  • Readers who enjoy meticulously researched historical fiction set in China would likely appreciate this book.
  • Those fascinated by traditional Chinese medicine, women's health practices, and the daily lives of women in imperial China will find much to engage with.
  • Fans of multigenerational stories focused on female friendships and overcoming societal restrictions may also connect with the narrative.
  • People interested in learning about lesser-known aspects of Chinese history and culture through an immersive fictional account would likely find value in this book.

Who is unlikely to appreciate this book?

  • Readers seeking fast-paced plots or strong character-driven narratives may struggle with this book's slower pacing and focus on historical detail.
  • Those sensitive to graphic descriptions of medical procedures or practices like foot binding should be cautious.
  • Readers expecting a more modern feminist perspective or characters who actively challenge societal norms may be disappointed.
  • Those who prefer less exposition and more showing through dialogue and action might find the writing style frustrating.
  • Readers looking for emotional depth or strong character development may also find the book lacking in these areas.

Things online reviewers enjoyed about this book

  • Well-researched and historically accurate portrayal of 15th century China
  • Fascinating insights into traditional Chinese medicine and women's health practices
  • Strong female characters and focus on women's friendships/support networks
  • Immersive descriptions of Chinese culture, customs, and daily life
  • Based on the true story of a remarkable female doctor
  • Highlights issues of gender inequality and women overcoming societal restrictions
  • Vivid depictions of different social classes and power dynamics
  • Explores themes of friendship, family, and personal growth
  • Engaging storyline spanning the protagonist's entire life
  • Sheds light on little-known aspects of Chinese history and medicine

Things people didn't like as much about this book

  • Pacing issues – some found it slow or boring in parts
  • Excessive focus on historical details at the expense of character development
  • Graphic descriptions of foot binding and medical procedures may be disturbing
  • Writing style felt explanatory/lecturing rather than showing through narrative
  • Lack of emotional depth or connection to characters for some readers
  • Oversimplification of Chinese language/concepts for Western audience
  • Too much emphasis on traditional gender roles without critique
  • Plot felt unfocused or meandering at times
  • Disappointing for readers expecting more feminist themes or character agency
  • Overuse of exposition rather than dialogue or action

If you like this book, you should consider reading:

by Kristin Hannah
by Abraham Verghese

About

Privacy Policy

RSS Feed